Let’s take a hard look at the arguments opponents use against Shepherd’s Run.
They say “it permanently removes 200+ acres of prime farmland.”
THE FACTS: Hecate has committed to an Agrivoltaics integration plan that will provide for sheep and pollinator farming. And Shepherd’s Run makes it possible for farmers to afford to stay on their land, allowing for cattle and corn raising to continue on a smaller part of the property.
They say “Shepherd’s Run is too big, and poorly sited.”
THE FACTS: To meet its ambitious climate goals — even assuming panels are built on most of our rooftops and parking areas —New York will need to build renewables on about 70,000 acres of farmland. The practical way to get this urgent task done is to use the acreage of willing landowners, on land close to substations. The Shepherd’s Run site meets these real-world criteria.
They say “it encroaches on sensitive wetlands and New York State protected watershed.”
THE FACTS: Shepherd’s Run will not affect the watershed. New York State has strict regulations about wetlands and solar developments. Also consider which has a greater impact on water quality: solar panels, or the fertilizers, pesticides and manure that currently pollute the groundwater?
They say “it disturbs key wildlife habitats and migration paths.”
THE FACTS: wildlife friendly fencing, selected in consultation with Columbia Land Conservancy, will be employed throughout the site.
They say “it violates the Law.”
THE FACTS. The Shepherd’s Run proposal is in accord with the laws of NY State. Because the development of renewable energy has lagged so dramatically, the CLCPA can overrule local laws. But before a local law can be set aside, Hecate has to show why each is “unduly burdensome” to the State’s climate goals.
They say “it hurts the local economy which depends or agriculture & tourism.”
THE FACTS: Plans are already underway to open a section of the old Harlem line for walking and cycling that runs through the site and will someday become part of the Harlem Valley Rail Trail. A dynamic solar project could put Copake on the map for new audiences/tourists.
They say “it ruins scenic views forever. ”
THE FACTS. Shepherd’s Run will occupy less than one percent of our town’s total land mass. Copake prides itself on its identity as a “Town of Rural Charm”. And when Shepherds Run becomes a reality, Copake will remain almost exactly as it is today: a “Town of Rural Charm.” But with a difference! We will have done our bit in confronting the climate crisis!